Heading into the Federal Open Market Committee’s policy meeting, analysts at Jefferies on May 3 advised investors to avoid the popular FAANG + Microsoft group of stocks.
They pointed instead to a group they named MANG. We’ll compare the two groups below.
The FAANG group — Facebook holding company Meta Platforms Inc.
and Google holding company Alphabet Inc.
— has been well-known to investors for many years. Those companies and Microsoft Corp.
were at the forefront of the long bull cycle for U.S. tech stocks. As you can see below, all of them are down significantly this year, but the worst performers have been Netflix and Meta.
On May 3, a team of analysts at Jefferies led by Sean Darby reiterated their February recommendation that investors steer clear of the FAANG + Microsoft group because the expected rise in interest rates would be especially hard on “long duration assets.”
Darby wrote that FAANG + Microsoft “is not a homogenous group” and repeated his recommendation for the MANG group.
He prefers the MANG group — Microsoft, Apple, Nvidia Corp.
and Alphabet — as a better basket for a rising rate environment, citing “their balance sheet, earnings yield and FCF [free cash flow] yield.”
Following the Federal Open Market Committee’s two-day policy meeting on May 3 and 4, the Federal Reserve is expected to raise the federal funds rate by 50 basis points to a range of 0.75% to 1.25% and announce a plan to reduce its bond holdings. Anticipating this tightening, Darby also warned investors that “the key message is patience.”
MANG vs. FAANG + MSFT
First, here’s some information about this year’s performance:
- The FAANG + Microsoft group lost $1.4 trillion in market value during April. You can see a breakdown of the individual value declines here. That was a 15% drop in only one month. The group’s market value was down $2.21 trillion, or 22%, for the first four months of 2022.
- The MANG group’s market value declined 14% during April and 18% for the first four months of the year.
Darby cited balance sheets, earnings yields and free cash flow yields backing his preference for the MANG group over the FAANG + Microsoft group. That means the odd group out is Meta Platforms, Amazon and Netflix.
So let’s look at two sets of figures and estimates to compare the groups, listing MANG names first, then the other three.
Debt, earnings yields and free cash flow yields
For comparison, here are the latest available ratios of long-term debt to equity for the group, along with earnings and free cash flow yields based on current share prices and consensus estimates for the next 12 months, and price-to-earnings ratios.
|Company||Ticker||Long-term debt/ equity||Forward EPS yield||Forward FCF yield||Forward P/E||Price change – 2002 through May 2|
|Alphabet Inc. Class C||7%||5.11%||5.42%||19.6||-19%|
|Meta Platforms Inc. Class A||FB||6%||5.99%||4.38%||16.7||-37%|
Click on the tickers for more about each company.
Click here for Tomi Kilgore’s detailed guide to the wealth of information for free on the MarketWatch quote page.
Darby favors the MANG group in part for balance-sheet strength, but Apple has a high ratio of long-term debt to equity.
The numbers clearly favor the MANG group for free cash flow yields. Meta Platforms is an exception, with the lowest level of debt to equity, the highest estimated earnings yield and the second-highest estimated FCF yield (after Alphabet). It also has the lowest forward price-to-earnings ratio of the group, following a 37% decline for its share price this year.
Looking further ahead
Here are estimated compound annual growth rates (CAGR) for the next two calendar years for sales, earnings per share and free cash flow:
|Company||Estimated sales ($mil) – 2022||Estimated sales ($mil) – 2023||Estimated sales ($mil) – 2024||Expected two-year Sales CAGR|
|Alphabet Inc. Class C||$298,939||$344,603||$395,114||15.0%|
|Meta Platforms Inc. Class A||$127,545||$148,154||$169,668||15.3%|
|Company||Estimated EPS – 2022||Estimated EPS – 2023||Estimated EPS – 2024||Expected two-year EPS CAGR|
|Alphabet Inc. Class C||$112.38||$133.96||$153.66||16.9%|
|Meta Platforms Inc. Class A||$11.90||$14.09||$16.21||16.7%|
|Company||Estimated FCF per share – 2022||Estimated FCF per share – 2023||Estimated FCF per share – 2024||Expected two-year FCF CAGR|
|Alphabet Inc. Class C||$118.40||$144.06||$168.20||19.2%|
|Meta Platforms Inc. Class A||$8.41||$10.88||$15.46||35.6%|
A consensus estimate for free cash flow isn’t available for Microsoft for 2024. Analysts expect the company’s FCF per share to increase by 18% in 2023.
What is striking about the CAGR estimates is that analysts are expecting very large increases in free cash flow for Amazon and Netflix, going out to 2024.
So when might it be time to jump back into the less-favored Meta, Amazon and Netflix?
Darby wrote: “[W]e are holding off for now on the economy slowing down sufficiently to look at acquiring 10-year Treasury equity proxies,” which include the FAANG + Microsoft group. He believes it is too early, and therefore continues to favor the MANG group for the rising-rate environment.
Don’t miss: These stocks soared during the pandemic, and then crashed. Ten are now expected to double in price.